Category: Apologetics

  • Is it Arrogant to Claim Jesus is the Only Way?

    Last week I spoke at Massey Presbyterian Church on the topic “Is it arrogant to claim Jesus is the only way?” The following is an abridged version of the talk I gave.

    ArrogantI was recently on a panel at Auckland University where an audience member raised the issue during the Q&A of religious pluralism. The issue is commonly raised as a rhetorical challenge, “isn’t it arrogant to believe Jesus is the only way?” In a world where there exists widespread religious pluralism, where there are people who are just as intelligent, educated, and ostensibly as sincere as we are who hold to and pratice a different religion to Christianity or no religion at all, how can a Christain maintain that she is right and everyone else is wrong. Isn’t believing that Jesus is the only way simply arrogant?

    In addressing this question I will first make three preliminary comments to identify what the issues are. Then, I will sketch three lines of response.

    First some prelimaries. As a matter of logic, if you affirm some proposition then you must reject the negation or denial of that proposition. Contradictory claims cannot both be true. It follows from this that in so far as one accepts the teachings of a religion like Christianity are true, as opposed to accepting the teachings for purely pragmatic reasons, one is rationally commited to rejecting claims that contradict this teaching. If one accepts God exists then it follows that one will believe that atheism, the denial of God’s existence, is false. If God created the world then the claim the world is not created is false. If Jesus died by crucifixition then the claim he did not exist or he died some other way is false.If there will be a final ressurection from the dead where people are judged for their actions then the claim there is no afterlife is false. So, if one accepts Christianity is true then one has to believe that other religions and perspectives that contradict Christianity are false; failure to believe this would be irrational.

    Second, accepting Christianity is true does not commit one to holding that there is no truth or value or good in other religions but it does commit one to the claim that these religions are mistaken where their teachings contradict the teachings of Christianity. This is signifcant as there are many issues on which different religions agree with Christianity, which makes them compatible with Christian teaching.

    Consider, for example Islam. Muslims believe there is only one God whom they call Allah. Allah is the Arabic word for God and was used by Christians to refer to God before the time of Mohamed. Muslims also believe that God is the creator and sustainer of the world. They believe God is all powerful, all knowing and has certain traits such as being just and merciful. Muslims believe God will judge all people and there will be a general ressurection of the dead. In all these things, Christians agree with them.

    Similarly, there are issues where Islam teaches about the way we should live that are perfectly compatible with Christian teachings, and which are arguably admirable given the standard Christian teachings on the same things. Muslims believe that one should give a third of one’s income to the poor, that one should pray five times a day.

    On the other hand, Islamic theology teaches things that are incompatible with central Christian doctrines. Muslim’s deny the Trinity, deny that Jesus was the son of God, deny that Jesus was crucified and that he rose from the dead. They affirm that Mohamaded is the final and ultimate prophet of Allah. Accepting Christianity commits one to denying these claims but not the former ones.

    What this shows is that Christians can accept that other religions and beliefs, and philosophers and theologians from within those traditions, can gain and appropriate genuine insight into the nature of God and his will for human kind. In fact, the Christian scriptures affirm this. In the first chapter of Romans the Apostle Paul states that “since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse.” Paul goes on to observe that this knowledge has been corrupted by Greco-Roman society but the point is that even behind such distortions is geniune insight of which the Pagans are (more…)

  • Hear Matt at MPC on: “Is it Narrow-Minded to Think Jesus is the Only Way?”

    This blog’s Matthew Flannagan will be speaking at Massey Presbytarian Church’s Night Church Service on the topic “Is it Narrow-Minded to Think Jesus is the Only Way?“

    Details are:

    MPC

    7:00pm (come at 6:30pm to grab a meal from the Night Church cafe)
    Sunday 29 September 2013
    Massey Presbyterian Church
    510 Don Buck Road, Auckland, New Zealand

    All welcome.

  • Advance: Exploring Tough Questions About Christianity

    This blog’s Matthew Flannagan is scheduled to speak alongside Dr Glenn Peoples, Dr Chris Tucker, Sean du Toit and Jacqui Lloyd at this Friday’s one day Auckland conference Advance: Exploring Tough Questions About Christianity.

    Advance: Exploring Tough Questions About Christianity

    From the promotional material:

    Are faith and reason enemies? Should we take Christianity seriously in the world of ideas? Can we even know that Christianity is true? Thinking Matters and Evangelical Union are proud to host Christian philosopher, blogger, and popular speaker Dr Glenn Peoples to explore these questions and examine the evidence.

    Workshops sessions available:

      • Dr Chris Tucker on the ‘problem of evil’
      • Shawn Means on maths, the universe, and God
      • Sean du Toit on who wrote the books of the New Testament
      • Dr Matthew Flannagan on reading difficult Old Testament passages

    The day will conclude with a panel featuring Dr Glenn Peoples, Dr Matthew Flannagan, and Jacqui Lloyd which is open to any question.

    The location is ‘GAPS’ 17A Powell St, Avondale – slightly out of the city (and a 10 min walk from Avondale train station), this rustic location is ideal for seminars and discussion.

    Cost: $15. Lunch is included.

    Register at the Facebook event page here.

  • Easter Sunday: Contemplating the Resurrection Accounts

    He RoseMatt preached the Easter Sunday message at Takanini Community Church this morning. Listen to his message  “Contemplating the Resurrection Accounts” online or download it as an MP3.

    (Read Matthew 28:1-15 first.)

    Related post: Good Friday: The Ritual of Contemplating the Cross

  • Why Defend Christianity? Hear Matthew Flannagan speak on Thursday

    Matt is speaking for Thinking Matters on the topic Why Defend Christianity? This coming Thursday, from the Facebook Event:

    Matthew Flannagan“The Christian faith seems increasingly at odds with those in the world around us. From the media, to skeptical teachers and unbelieving peers, the gospel seems irrelevant and out of date. How do we talk to others about God and the Bible? Can we really argue people into the kingdom of God? Or should we just focus on compassion and loving others? Next Thursday, Thinking Matters Auckland is hosting Christian theologian Dr Matt Flannagan to speak on these questions and more. Matt will examine the Biblical and practical evidence for defending Christianity and show why it is vital to knowing and communicating our faith in the 21st Century. The event is free, so come along and bring a friend.

    Matt is a theologian and prominent New Zealand Christian commentator, debater, and blogger. He specialises in applied ethics and the interface between philosophy and theology. Currently, Matt works part-time as a teaching pastor and youth group leader for Takanini Church of Christ while he runs the popular blog MandM with his wife Madeleine.

    Thinking Matters is a New Zealand Christian ministry that exists to encourage the life of the mind in the love of God.”

    Thursday 4 April @ 7.30pm @ Auckland Chinese Presbyterian Church, 105 Vincent Street, Auckland, New Zealand

  • Hear Matt Speak at Stayin’ Alive Pro Life Training Day

    The Autumn 2013 Stayin’ Alive Pro-Life Training Day will be held in Christchurch this Saturday 16 March 2013. Matt will be speaking twice.

    Stayin' Alive Autumn 2013

    8:15am Rego’s and tea & coffee (YouTube videos in main hall)
    9:00am Introduction, housekeeping, and ice breaker (people bingo)
    09:30am session: ‘Relativism, Utilitarianism and Abortion’ – Dr Matthew Flannagan
    10:30am Morning tea break
    10:50am session: ‘Abortion Apologetics’ – Brendan Malone
    11:50pm Break
    12:00pm session: ‘The media and the culture of life’ – Bob McCoskrie
    12:45pm Lunch Break
    13:30pm WORKSHOPS:

    1. ‘Modern medicine and abortion’ – Dr C. Hallagan
    2. ‘The truth about post-abortion trauma’ – Carolina Gnad
    3. ‘Practical media skills’ – Bob McCoskrie

    14:30pm Break
    14:45pm WORKSHOPS:

    1. ‘What women in crisis-pregnancy need from us’ – Sandra Martin
    2. ‘Using the Internet to build a culture of life’ – Jason McTague
    3. ‘Skills every pro-life apologist needs’ – Dr Matthew Flannagan

    15:45pm Afternoon tea break
    16:15pm session ‘Be the voice your culture needs you to be!’ – Brendan Malone
    17:00pm Small group discussion
    17:15pm Final wrap up
    17:45pm BBQ Dinner
    19:00pm Finish and clean up

    When and where:
    Saturday 16 March, 2013 at:

    Burwood Christian Centre
    54 Bassett Street
    Burwood
    Christchurch

    Registration starts at 8:45am on Saturday 16 March, and the event runs all day finishing with a BBQ dinner at approximately 5:45pm.

    The registration fee is $20 per person (includes lunch and dinner plus morning and afternoon tea).

    More information including how to register is available on the Stayin’ Alive website.

  • Apologetics in Auckland

    Here in New Zealand, I am often told by evangelical leaders that we now live in a post-modern society, which has moved beyond “arguments” and that Apologetics is an outdated “modernist concept.” They say we need instead to “tell the story” so that people will see the “meta-narrative of scripture”—whatever exactly that means.

    ScalesLast night, Madeleine and I were invited to a Christmas function for new lawyers, organised by the Law Society, the professional association for lawyers in New Zealand. The function was in a major law firm in central Auckland’s business district. So I was right in the thick of the up-and-coming legal professionals in New Zealand.

    Anyway, Madeleine struck up a conversation with some young lawyers who were working for an arm of the government. They discussed aspects of their respective legal professions. Then one of them turned to me and asked me, “what do you do?” I answered that I was a theologian. Immediately, this caused them to pause (it often has this effect) and one told me he had been reading a book called The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins. Without thinking, I said, “Oh, that book, it’s crap.” He replied, “Yeah, but you have to say that, don’t you?” I responded, “No I don’t actually.” I then mentioned to him the works of some other atheists to whom I would not respond in that fashion, despite the fact I disagreed with their conclusions.

    Then, for the next thirty minutes, these lawyers began asking me genuine questions about the Christian faith. One asked me immediately, “why don’t you refrain from eating shellfish given the Old Testament prohibits it?” He was not being hostile; he was interested. I explained how the food laws functioned to set Israel apart from other nations and how, in the New Testament era, Gentiles were incorporated as part of God’s people, meaning the barrier between Jew and Gentile lacked relevance.

    Then one asked me, “I have heard the evidence for Jesus is as good, if not better, than that for other historical figures—is that true?” I discussed with him the sources we have for Alexander the Great and how they compared with the Gospels in terms of time, discussed how people date the gospels to confirm it, and mentioned the age of the epistles. We then discussed the supernatural aspects of the narrative and Hume’s arguments about miracles. They were fascinated.

    Next came a question about pagan mythology and parallels with Jesus. One then said, “wouldn’t a really popular guy like Jesus be written about by everyone?” I explained why this assumption was mistaken and one other lawyer said, “Yeah, I suppose expecting the Romans to write about Jesus is like expecting Washington, D.C. to write about the Aramoana incident.” (When non-New Zealander’s respond to this with “What’s the Aramoana incident?” their question illustrates nicely the point being made.)

    I then discussed Josephus’s reference to Jesus, Tacitus, the Talmud and so on. Each then opened up to me and told me of their own spiritual struggles and journey. To my considerable surprise, when one of them was called away from conversation some 30 to 40 minutes latter, ending the discussion, he stated to his beckoning companion, “Hey, you missed a really interesting discussion we had over here. This guy’s a theologian; he is not a try-hard ex-Catholic like you, he is the real thing.” This companion’s girlfriend then responded, as though she was viewing an exhibit in the zoo or a museum, “Is he a minister?” and then my interlocutor relayed to his companions how interesting and fruitful he considered the conversation to have been as they moved over to his friend.

    They moved on, but one lawyer who was nearby came over to us, (more…)