Category: Philosophy of Religion

  • Video: “Discussing Divine Command Theory” Special Guest: Matthew Flannagan

    Last week I was invited to be part of a discussion on divine command ethics in Google hangouts. The full discussion is now on-line as episode 22 of Ode to Dialogue: “Discussing Divine Command Theory.” Enjoy.

  • Ethical Supernaturalism is still more Plausible than Naturalism: Carrier’s Preliminary Objections

    Last year I had an article Is Ethical Naturalism more plausible than Supernaturalism: A reply to Walter Sinnott Armstrong published in the journal Philo. In the comments section a reader asked me to comment on a response to that article published by classical historian Richard Carrier. This post will be the first of several where I do so.Carrier

    In, Is Ethical Naturalism more Plausible than Supernaturalism, I did two things. Firstly, I briefly explicated a conditional that has recently been proposed explicitly by William Lane Craig but which is also defended by several others, and secondly I rebutted several arguments raised against this conditional by Walter Sinnott-Armstrong. Carrier argues my rebuttals fail, but before he does so he offers three preliminary arguments against the positive thesis I was defending against Armstrong. It is these that I will address in this post.

    The Contention

    The conditional I explicated as follows:

    Craig’s contention is that if theism is true then we can plausibly explain the nature of moral obligation by identifying obligations with God’s commands, analogous to the way “we explain the nature of water by identifying it with H2O, or explain the nature of heat by identifying it with molecular motion.” By “God” Craig means a necessarily existent, all-powerful, all-knowing, loving and just, immaterial person who created and providentially orders the universe.[1]

    Note three things.

    First, this is a conditional, if affirms that if theism is true then then we can plausibly explain the nature of moral obligation by identifying obligations with God’s commands.

    Second, I define the concept of God used in this conditional as a necessarily existent, all-powerful, all-knowing, loving and just, immaterial person who created and providentially orders the universe.

    Third, this conditional specifies the kind of grounding relationship I am addressing, one where the relationship between God’s commands and moral obligations is one of identity. It’s the same kind of (more…)

  • “Telling the Big Story” (or how not to engage culture with theology)

    One thing that tends to make my eyes glaze over is the mantra, expressed so frequently by some evangelicals in New Zealand,  that we live in a post-modern society and so theology should, instead of involving the rational defense of truth, be focused on “telling the big story” or “sharing the narrative”, and we should invite others to partake and find meaning.

    William Lane Craig, expresses well some of the reservations I have with this position in the video below.

  • True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New Atheism – in Paperback

    True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New AtheismThe paperback version of the Kindle book, True Reason: Christian Responses to the Challenges of Atheism,  which Matt wrote a chapter for, recently arrived from the publishers. This release has been re-released as True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New Atheism (the link takes you to the book’s official website).

    True Reason is still edited by Tom Gilson and Carson Weitnauer and is still published by Kregal Publications; however, this edition has been updated and expanded and it has two additional chapters. The table of contents is as follows:

    1. The Party of Reason?
      Tom Gilson
    2. The Irony of Atheism
      Carson Weitnauer
    3. Dawkins’s Delusion
      William Lane Craig
    4. Richard Dawkins’s Illusions
      Chuck Edwards
    5. Unreason at the Head of Project Reason
      Tom Gilson
    6. John Loftus and the “Outsider-Insider Test for Faith”
      David Marshall
    7. Atheism and the Argument from Reason*
      Lenny Esposito
    8. The Explanatory Emptiness of Naturalism
      David Wood
    9. Reason in a Christian Context
      Peter Grice
    10. The Marriage of Faith and Reason
      David Marshall
    11. Faith and Reason in Historical Perspective*
      David Marshall and Timothy McGrew
    12. A Sun to See By—Christianity, Meaning, and Morality
      Samuel J. Youngs
    13. Are Science and Christianity at Odds?
      Sean McDowell
    14. God and Science Do Mix
      Tom Gilson
    15. The Problem of Evil and Reasonable Christian Responses
      John DePoe
    16. Historical Evidences for the Gospels
      Randy Hardman
    17. Did God Command the Genocide of the Canaanites?
      Matthew Flannagan
    18. Christianity and Slavery
      Glenn Sunshine
    19. Epilogue
      Carson Weitnauer

    *Chapters Seven and Eleven are new additions in the second edition, not included in the Kindle version of True Reason.

    Read the author’s bios here.

    The blurb from Amazon is as follows:

    Today’s New Atheists proclaim themselves our culture’s party of reason. It is a claim they cannot sustain. Reason is the New Atheists’ weakness, not their strength and in fact, the Christian faith is a far better place to look for True Reason.

    In sixteen carefully constructed essays by more than a dozen Christian thinkers including William Lane Craig, Sean McDowell, and Timothy McGrew,True Reason unmasks the frequent irrationality displayed by leading atheists like Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, and Christopher Hitchens. The authors go on to show the great extent to which the Christian faith has historically supported sound reasoning, and that Christian thinkers, past and present, have demonstrated real excellence in reasoned, rational thinking.

    Making their case accessible to the first-time inquirer as well as the serious student, this top-flight team of writers presents a sound defense and a strong introduction to the true reason uniquely found in Christianity.

    You can buy the paperback version of True Reason: Confronting the Irrationality of the New Atheism on Amazon here.

  • Dialogue with Randal Rauser

    When I was in Baltimore last November I caught up with fellow theologian and blogger Randal Rauser. Randal is professor of Theology at Taylor Seminary in Edmonton Canada.

    Randal and I have had some spirited but cordial exchanges in the past, including a panel discussion at the Society of Biblical Literature in 2010.While we do not always agree I find him to be a very astute critic of my work.

    Randal Rauser and Matthew Flannagan

    Randal asked to interview me in Baltimore on the topic “Matthew Flannagan on God, ethics, and divine commands” so the readers of his blog could get a take on the positions I have staked out. The interview is now available at the link above.

  • Back from Baltimore

    The following is a belated report of my recent trip to Baltimore. I began writing the post in December, but Christmas, New Year, the holidays, and various other things got in the way of me finally completing it.

    On Tuesday 26 November 2013 I flew back to New Zealand having attended the annual conference of the Evangelical Theological Society (ETS), Evangelical Philosophical Society (EPS), and Evangelical Philosophical Society Apologetics (Apologetics) conferences in Baltimore. My trip year was shorter than my month long tour the previous year and a lot more intense, but it was still very rewarding.

    The first session I attended was a panel involving Micheal Bird, Al Mohler and Peter Enns and Van Hoozer on inerrancy. There were no surprises here. Al Mohler took the line that inerrancy, as defined by the Chicago statement, must be retained and that denying it was a kind of slippery slope to all sorts of doctrinal error. Peter Enns asserted a whole lot of alleged problems with inerrancy; he assumed that the issues he raised were a fait accompli, ignored any critical responses to them and dismissed theological arguments as a priori without engaging the premises. Van Hoozer spelt out his own position in terms of speech act theory.

    Michael Bird was perhaps the exception in terms of stating the expected; he pointed out correctly, in my view, that the debate on inerrancy tended to presuppose a North American context. He argued that the kinds of cultural battles which contributed to the American debate had not played out the same way in evangelicalism outside the USA. This, I think, is entirely correct. Unfortunately there was little engagement between speakers. I would have liked to heard how each responded to the premises and arguments of their opponents.

    The next session of note was David Baggett speaking on “the vices of virtue theory”. Baggett is working on a sequel to the book Good God: The Theistic Foundations of Morality which he co-wrote with Jerry Walls. In this paper Baggett raised some trenchant criticisms of Philippa Foot’s book Natural Goodness. Foot defends a naturalistic account of goodness in terms of the natural flourishing of a species. The gist of Baggett’s criticism was that Foot is unable to really rise above amoral accounts of goodness, such as when we say that a good tiger tears apart its prey well.

    In the afternoon I attended an interesting paper by Christian Milhut about whether resentment can be a virtue. Milhut was critical of the idea that our feelings of resentment and anger at perceived injustices are reliable. This paper elicited an interesting discussion about when such emotions are and are not appropriate in morality.

    The evening saw the EPS reception, where Gary DeWeese gave a thoughtful address on the role of fellowship in Christian philosophy. This was followed by nibbles, socialising and mingling.

    On the Wednesday I began at 8:30 am by attending a paper by Peter Payne on “Objectivity in debates over whether Ethics needs God”. This was followed by a paper by Harry Bunting entitled “Divine Authority A Kantian Perspective”. Bunting’s paper was excellent. He noted that while Immanuel Kant viewed morality’s content as dependent on reason, but maintained Kant believed the moral law was only obligatory on humans because God held human beings accountable to the standards reason laid down. Bunting brought this perspective of God’s authority being linked to him holding humans accountable into dialogue with Mark Murphy’s celebrated position on divine authority in “an essay on divine authority”. Bunting’s paper was extremely interesting and I hope to get a copy of this paper in the future as (more…)

  • Matt to speak at the EPS Apologetics Conference in Baltimore on Morality and God’s Commands

    This blog’s Matthew Flannagan has been invited to speak at the 12th Annual Apologetics Conference of the Evangelical Philosophical Society in Baltimore, USA. The theme of this year’s conference is Reasonable Faith in an Uncertain World. Matt’s talk is titled “Morality and God’s Commands: Answering Common Objections.” The blurb for Matt’s talk is as follows:

    EPS Apologetics Conference

    “It is widely believed in contemporary philosophy that morality does not depend on God. Theories that attempt to identify our moral obligations with God’s commands are believed to be subject to several important objections. In this talk I will offer reasons for rejecting this position. I will clarify what it means to claim our moral duties depend on God’s commands and I will distinguish this claim from various misconceptions. I will then examine the most common objections to this position and that show they fail.”

    Matt is the only New Zealand speaker and he will be speaking alongside some of the top Christian thinkers and speakers in the world such as Dr. Gary Habermas, Sean McDowell, Dr. Paul Copan, Mary Jo Sharp, Dr. Craig Hazen, Dr. John Bloom, Greg Koukl, Dr. Mark Foreman, Patty Houser, Dr. Angus Menuge, and many more. You can see a full list of speakers here. Check out the sessions and tracks for the the EPS Apologetics Conference, which runs from 21-23 November 2013, and register here.

    Matt is also speaking at the annual meetings of the Evangelical Theological Society, on Feticide, and the Evangelical Philosophical Society, on Divine Commands re Abraham and Issac,  in Baltimore earlier in the week. (See Matt to speak at the 2013 Evangelical Theological Society in Baltimore on Feticide and Matt to speak at the 2013 Evangelical Philosophical Society in Baltimore on Divine Commands re Abraham and Isaac).

    If you are minded to support his and my fundraising efforts to get him to Baltimore for his 3 speaking engagements next week, please consider donating using one of the methods in the side bar.